Choosing the right tires from Goodyear’s extensive lineup requires matching specific driving conditions to the correct tread compound and sidewall construction. The Goodyear Assurance ComfortDrive stands out as the best overall choice for daily commuters who prioritize a quiet ride and consistent wet traction. For drivers needing rugged capability without sacrificing highway manners, the Goodyear Wrangler Territory AT offers a superior balance of off-road grip and on-road stability. The main tradeoff in this category is between tread life and aggressive traction; softer compounds grip better but wear faster. This guide breaks down fifteen distinct models to help you identify which tire fits your vehicle’s load index and your personal driving habits.
Get business pricing on garage and car supplies
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Comfort vs. Control: The Assurance ComfortDrive and Assurance Finesse prioritize noise reduction and ride smoothness, making them ideal for luxury sedans, whereas the Eagle RS-A2 sacrifices some quietness for sharper cornering response.
- All-Terrain Versatility: The Wrangler Territory AT and Wrangler TrailRunner AT bridge the gap between highway tires and serious off-road rubber, but the TrailRunner’s deeper siping offers better mud traction at the cost of higher road noise.
- SUV-Specific Fit: The Fortera HL is engineered specifically for heavy SUVs and crossovers, providing stiffer sidewalls to counteract body roll, unlike standard passenger tires like the Assurance All-Season which may feel vague under heavy loads.
- High-Performance Limits: The Eagle RS-A2 and Eagle RS-A are the only options here with Y-speed ratings, indicating they are built for sports sedans and performance coupes, not daily grocery getters.
- Light Truck Durability: The Wrangler DuraTrac RT features a reinforced sidewall and deeper tread blocks compared to the Wrangler SR-A, making it the superior choice for drivers who occasionally tow or drive on gravel.
| Goodyear tire | Load index | Construction | Season | Tire size |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goodyear Wrangler TrailRunner | 115 | Radial | Year-round | 275/60R20 |
| Goodyear Wrangler Territory HT | 103 | Radial | — | — |
| Goodyear Assurance All-Season | 95 | Radial | Year-round | — |
| Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RT | 116 | Radial | — | 275/65R18 |
| Goodyear Eagle Touring All-Sea | 102 | — | — | 235/55R20 102V |
| Goodyear Fortera HL All-Season | 110 (2,150 lbs) | Radial | All-Season | 265/50R20 |
| Goodyear Eagle Touring All-Sea | 99 (1,709 lbs) | Radial | All-Season | 245/45R20 99V |
| Goodyear Eagle RS-A2 All-Seaso | 99 (1,709 lbs) | Radial | All-Season | 245/45ZR20 99Y |
| Goodyear Eagle LS2 All-Season | 97 (1,609 lbs) | Radial | All-Season | 235/50R18 97H |
| Goodyear Eagle RS-A P245/50R20 | 102 (1,874 lbs) | Radial, 4-ply | All-Season | P245/50R20 102H |
| Goodyear Assurance ComfortDriv | 105 | Radial | All-Season | — |
| Goodyear Assurance Finesse All | 105 | 4-ply Radial | All-Season | — |
| Goodyear Wrangler SR-A All-Sea | 114 | Radial | All-Season | — |
| Goodyear Wrangler Territory AT | 115 | 4-Ply Radial | All-Season | — |
| Goodyear Assurance Finesse All | 103 | 4-ply Radial | Year-round | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Goodyear Wrangler TrailRunner AT All-Season Tire, 275/60R20 115S
The Wrangler TrailRunner AT is the most versatile truck-focused choice here for drivers who split time between pavement and occasional rough or muddy routes. Its interlocking tread blocks and multi-angle sipes are intended to maintain traction across changing surfaces, while stepped shoulders add bite in snow and mud. Compared with the highway-oriented Wrangler Territory HT, this model gives up some emphasis on a smooth, quiet ride in favor of more off-road capability. The tread is also designed to limit noise and support longer wear, and its stated 55,000-mile limited tread warranty is the longest mileage coverage among these five. That warranty has exclusions, though, and this is not a dedicated severe-winter tire. Choose it for mixed use, not frequent technical off-roading.
Pros:- Tread design targets both paved-road and off-road traction
- Stepped shoulders help add grip in deep snow and mud
- Optimized pattern is designed to reduce road noise and extend tread life
- Limited tread life warranty is listed for 55,000 miles
Cons:- More off-road-oriented than the Wrangler Territory HT, making it less specifically suited to highway comfort
- Warranty exclusions apply
- No detailed braking or severe-winter performance figures are provided
Best for: Pickup and SUV owners who commute on pavement but regularly drive gravel roads, muddy access routes, or occasional snowy terrain
Not ideal for: Drivers who spend nearly all their time on highways and prioritize a quiet, road-focused ride, or those who need dedicated winter capability
- Tire size:275/60R20
- Rim size:20 inches
- Load index:115
- Load capacity:2,679 pounds
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Tread type:Symmetrical
- Construction:Radial
- Season:Year-round
- Warranty:Limited tread life warranty, 55,000 miles; exclusions apply
Our verdict“Choose the TrailRunner AT if your truck or SUV needs one tire for everyday roads and occasional rough terrain rather than highway use alone.”
Goodyear Wrangler Territory HT 225/55R19 103H All-Season Tire
The Wrangler Territory HT favors predictable highway manners over trail-focused traction. Its ribbed tread pattern and tuned tread pitch are designed to reduce pattern noise, which suits truck and SUV drivers who spend most of their time on paved roads. Compared with the more terrain-oriented Wrangler TrailRunner AT, this tire is the clearer pick for a smooth, quiet commute, but the supplied details make no specific claims about snow, mud, or wet-weather performance. Its extra-load rating and 1,929-pound load capacity provide useful load information for buyers matching a replacement tire to their vehicle, but they do not substitute for checking the vehicle placard. It is sold as one tire, so buyers replacing a full set need to account for four units and confirm fitment.
Pros:- Tuned tread pitch is designed to reduce pattern noise
- Ribbed tread aims for a smooth highway ride
- All-season design for truck and SUV highway use
- XL load range and 1,929-pound stated load capacity
Cons:- Sold as a single tire rather than a complete set
- Product details provide no specific wet-weather or snow-performance claims
- Less suited to trail use than the Wrangler TrailRunner AT
Best for: Truck and SUV owners with 225/55R19 fitment who mainly drive highways and want an all-season tire designed for a quieter ride
Not ideal for: Drivers who need described off-road, deep-snow, or wet-weather capability, or shoppers expecting a complete set in one purchase
- Size:225/55R19
- Rim size:19 inches
- Load index:103
- Load capacity:1,929 pounds
- Maximum pressure:50 psi
- Tread depth:8.57 millimeters
- Construction:Radial
- Load range:XL
- Quantity:1 tire
Our verdict“Pick the Territory HT for a highway-focused truck or SUV that prioritizes a quiet ride and has the correct 225/55R19 fitment.”
Goodyear Assurance All-Season Radial Tire, 215/60R16 95T
For a passenger car that needs a straightforward year-round replacement, the Assurance All-Season balances wet, dry, and light snowy-road traction with a 65,000-mile mileage warranty. Its grooves are designed to move water and slush away from the tread, while stable shoulder blocks support controlled handling. This makes it a more all-purpose passenger-car choice than the larger, truck-focused Wrangler TrailRunner AT, which is built around mixed road and off-road use. The Assurance also targets lower road noise, a practical advantage for daily commuting. The tradeoff is that the supplied information gives no braking distances or other quantified performance results, so buyers seeking measured performance comparisons will need more vehicle- and tire-specific data. Match the 215/60R16 size and load requirements to the vehicle before buying.
Pros:- Designed for wet, dry, and snowy-road traction
- Tread grooves help clear water and slush
- Stable shoulder blocks support confident handling
- 65,000-mile mileage warranty
Cons:- No specific braking-distance or quantified performance figures are provided
- Passenger-car focus is less appropriate than the Wrangler TrailRunner AT for off-road use
Best for: Commuters and small-family-car owners with 215/60R16 fitment who want year-round road use and a stated mileage warranty
Not ideal for: Truck and SUV owners needing off-road traction, or drivers who require quantified braking and winter-performance data before choosing
- Size:215/60R16
- Rim size:16 inches
- Load index:95
- Load capacity:1,521 pounds
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Tread depth:9/32 inches
- Construction:Radial
- Season:Year-round
- Warranty:65,000-mile mileage warranty
Our verdict“Choose the Assurance All-Season for everyday passenger-car driving if its size fits and you value broad seasonal use with stated mileage coverage.”
Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RT All-Season Radial Tire, 275/65R18, Set of 1
The Wrangler DuraTrac RT is the most protection-focused option in this group. Its Kevlar reinforcement and three-ply Durawall sidewall are aimed at resisting punctures, cuts, and abrasions, making it a stronger match for rough routes than the more mixed-use Wrangler TrailRunner AT. The asymmetrical tread is also designed to add biting edges for snow and off-road grip. That extra emphasis on durability comes with practical tradeoffs: it is sold as one tire, so a full vehicle set requires separate purchases, and its warranty details are inconsistent in the supplied information—the description cites up to 50,000 miles, while the warranty field lists 45,000 miles. Buyers should confirm applicable coverage before purchase. Its 275/65R18 fitment also limits it to vehicles designed for that size.
Pros:- Kevlar reinforcement is designed to add strength and resist tread damage
- Three-ply Durawall sidewall targets puncture, cut, and abrasion resistance
- Asymmetrical tread is designed for snow and off-road grip
- Load capacity is listed at 2,756 pounds
Cons:- Sold as a single tire, requiring separate purchases for a full set
- Warranty mileage conflicts between the description and warranty field
- Rugged construction and trail focus are less tailored to quiet highway driving than the Wrangler Territory HT
Best for: Truck and SUV owners with 275/65R18 fitment who regularly encounter rocky, abrasive, or snowy off-road routes
Not ideal for: Drivers focused on quiet paved-road commuting, shoppers needing a complete set at once, or buyers who want unambiguous warranty mileage
- Tire size:275/65R18
- Rim size:18 inches
- Load index:116
- Load capacity:2,756 pounds
- Maximum pressure:50 psi
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Load range:XL
- Construction:Radial
- Warranty:Warranty field lists 45,000 miles; description states up to 50,000 miles
Our verdict“Choose the DuraTrac RT if sidewall protection and off-road durability matter more than highway refinement, after confirming fitment and warranty terms.”
Goodyear Eagle Touring All-Season Tire, 235/55R20 102V
The Eagle Touring is the passenger-oriented pick here for drivers who want a composed ride and responsive handling in a 20-inch fitment. Its asymmetrical tread and optimized contact area are intended to support steering response, while the design also targets a smooth, quiet ride. Compared with the smaller Assurance All-Season, this tire is built around a different fitment and emphasizes touring-style responsiveness rather than a stated 65,000-mile warranty. The supplied product information does not include a mileage warranty or specific wet- and snow-performance claims, so buyers should not infer those details from its all-season label. It is also a poor match for truck owners seeking the trail traction of either Wrangler option. Check the vehicle’s required size and load rating before choosing it.
Pros:- Asymmetrical tread is designed to support handling
- Optimized contact area aims to improve responsiveness
- Designed for a smooth, quiet ride
- 20-inch fitment for vehicles requiring 235/55R20
Cons:- No specific drawbacks or performance limitations are stated in the product information
- No mileage warranty is listed in the supplied specifications
- Less suited to off-road use than the Wrangler TrailRunner AT or DuraTrac RT
Best for: Drivers with 235/55R20 fitment who want an all-season touring tire designed for responsive handling and a quieter ride
Not ideal for: Truck and SUV owners seeking off-road traction, or buyers who require stated mileage coverage or detailed snow-performance claims
- Tire size:235/55R20 102V
- Rim size:20 inches
- Load index:102
- Load capacity:1,875 pounds
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Tread depth:9/32 inches
- Rim width:7.5 inches
- Tire diameter:30.2 inches
- Sidewall:Black
Our verdict“Choose the Eagle Touring for a compatible 20-inch passenger vehicle when responsive touring manners matter more than off-road ability or documented mileage coverage.”
Goodyear Fortera HL All-Season Radial Tire, 265/50R20
This tire is engineered specifically for trucks and large SUVs, offering a higher load capacity than the passenger-focused Eagle LS2. Its non-directional tread design prioritizes stable handling and even wear, which is critical for heavy vehicles that can chew through tires unevenly. While it lacks the aggressive off-road capability of the Wrangler series, it provides a smoother, quieter ride on pavement. The 60,000-mile warranty is a significant advantage over the shorter warranties found on some performance-oriented models in this lineup. However, buyers should note that this tire is not designed for high-speed spirited driving, focusing instead on comfort and longevity for daily commuting.
Pros:- Higher load capacity suitable for heavy SUVs
- 60,000-mile limited tread life warranty
- Non-directional tread promotes even wear
- Optimized for a quiet highway ride
Cons:- Not designed for high-speed performance driving
- Warranty exclusions may limit coverage in certain scenarios
Best for: Owners of large SUVs and crossovers who prioritize a quiet ride and long tread life over sporty handling.
Not ideal for: Drivers seeking high-performance cornering or off-road capability, as the tread is optimized for highway comfort.
- Tire Size:265/50R20
- Load Index:110 (2,150 lbs)
- Season:All-Season
- Tread Type:Non-directional
- Warranty:60,000 miles
- Construction:Radial
- Max Pressure:51 psi
Our verdict“Choose this if you drive a heavy SUV and want a reliable, long-lasting all-season tire with a strong warranty.”
Goodyear Eagle Touring All-Season Passenger Tire, 245/45R20 99V
The Eagle Touring strikes a balance between comfort and light sportiness, making it a versatile choice for sedans and CUVs. Compared to the Fortera HL, this tire is lighter and designed for lower-profile rims, offering sharper steering response without sacrificing too much comfort. The symmetrical tread pattern is designed to minimize road noise and vibration, which is a key advantage for daily commuters. While it handles wet roads well thanks to circumferential grooves, it does not offer the extreme grip of the Eagle RS-A2 in dry conditions. It is an excellent middle-ground option for those who want a premium feel without the high wear rates of performance tires.
Pros:- Optimized for reduced road noise and vibration
- Balanced traction for dry, wet, and light snow
- Symmetrical design aids in even wear
- Fits a wide range of passenger vehicles
Cons:- Less aggressive cornering capability than sport tires
- Standard warranty may be shorter than some competitors
Best for: Sedan and CUV drivers who want a quiet, smooth ride with decent all-season capability.
Not ideal for: Performance enthusiasts who need maximum dry grip, as the touring compound is softer than sport options.
- Tire Size:245/45R20 99V
- Load Index:99 (1,709 lbs)
- Season:All-Season
- Tread Type:Symmetrical
- Tread Depth:10/32 inches
- Construction:Radial
- Max Pressure:51 psi
Our verdict“A solid choice for everyday drivers seeking a quiet, comfortable tire with reliable all-season performance.”
Goodyear Eagle RS-A2 All-Season Radial Tire, 245/45ZR20 99Y
If you prioritize cornering stability and dry grip, the Eagle RS-A2 outperforms the more comfort-focused Eagle Touring. The asymmetric tread design is engineered to provide better traction during aggressive maneuvers, making it ideal for drivers who enjoy a more engaging drive. The wide grooves effectively channel water to prevent hydroplaning, though the softer sport compound may wear faster than the Fortera HL. This tire is rated for higher speeds (Y rating), indicating its capability to handle spirited driving conditions. It is a direct competitor to other ultra-high-performance all-season tires, offering a blend of sporty aesthetics and practical all-season utility.
Pros:- Asymmetric tread enhances cornering grip
- High-speed rated (Y) for spirited driving
- Wide grooves improve wet weather safety
- Sporty appearance and performance balance
Cons:- Potentially shorter tread life than touring tires
- May produce more road noise than comfort-focused models
Best for: Drivers with sporty sedans or coupes who want enhanced handling and high-speed stability.
Not ideal for: Commuters who prioritize maximum tread life and a silent cabin, as the sport design can be noisier.
- Tire Size:245/45ZR20 99Y
- Load Index:99 (1,709 lbs)
- Season:All-Season
- Tread Type:Asymmetrical
- Construction:Radial
- Weight:28 pounds
Our verdict“Pick this if you want a tire that looks and feels sporty while still handling rain and light snow.”
Goodyear Eagle LS2 All-Season Radial Tire, 235/50R18 97H
The Eagle LS2 serves as an accessible entry into Goodyear’s performance-touring segment. While it shares the 55,000-mile warranty focus with other touring tires, its directional tread pattern is specifically designed to evacuate water quickly, offering a safety edge in rainy conditions compared to symmetrical designs like the Eagle Touring. It is lighter and smaller than the Fortera HL, making it suitable for smaller crossovers and sedans. The trade-off is that it may not offer the same level of high-speed stability as the Eagle RS-A2, but for most daily drivers, the smooth ride quality and predictable handling make it a sensible, cost-effective choice.
Pros:- Directional tread excels at water evacuation
- 55,000-mile limited tread life warranty
- Quiet ride quality for daily commuting
- Confident cornering for a touring tire
Cons:- Lower speed rating than sport-oriented Eagle models
- May not fit larger SUVs or trucks
Best for: Drivers of mid-size sedans and crossovers looking for a balance of wet-weather safety and value.
Not ideal for: Large SUV owners, as the load index and size are not designed for heavy vehicles.
- Tire Size:235/50R18 97H
- Load Index:97 (1,609 lbs)
- Season:All-Season
- Tread Type:Directional
- Warranty:55,000 miles
- Construction:Radial
- Weight:28 pounds
Our verdict“A reliable, wet-weather capable tire for standard passenger vehicles seeking good value and longevity.”
Goodyear Eagle RS-A P245/50R20 102H SL All-Season Tire
This tire bridges the gap between the lighter Eagle Touring and the heavier Fortera HL. With a higher load index (102) than the LS2 or Touring, it is better suited for heavier crossovers and light SUVs that need extra stability. The asymmetric tread provides better cornering support than the symmetrical Eagle Touring, while the 4-ply construction offers a stiffer sidewall for improved handling. Unlike the Eagle RS-A2, which is rated for higher speeds, the RS-A focuses on durability and consistent performance across a wide range of conditions. It is a practical choice for drivers who want a bit more ruggedness than a standard sedan tire without moving to a truck-specific model.
Pros:- Higher load capacity (102) for heavier vehicles
- Asymmetric tread improves cornering stability
- 4-ply construction adds sidewall rigidity
- Balanced performance in wet and dry conditions
Cons:- Heavier weight may slightly impact fuel economy
- Limited detailed performance data in standard listings
Best for: Drivers of heavier crossovers and light SUVs who need extra load capacity and stable handling.
Not ideal for: Performance drivers seeking high-speed ratings, as this tire is optimized for all-season durability.
- Tire Size:P245/50R20 102H
- Load Index:102 (1,874 lbs)
- Season:All-Season
- Tread Type:Asymmetrical
- Construction:Radial, 4-ply
- Weight:32 pounds
- Max Pressure:51 psi
Our verdict“Ideal for crossover owners who need a sturdy, all-season tire with better load support than standard passenger tires.”
Goodyear Assurance ComfortDrive All-Season Tire, 245/60R18
This tire prioritizes a smooth, quiet ride, making it a strong choice for drivers who value cabin silence over aggressive handling. AquaChannel grooves are engineered specifically to reduce hydroplaning, offering a safety net in heavy rain that feels more robust than the standard Assurance series. Compared to the Goodyear Eagle Touring, the ComfortDrive trades some cornering stiffness for a softer, more forgiving ride quality. The 65,000-mile tread life warranty is a standout feature, signaling confidence in long-term durability. However, the non-directional tread means rotation options are flexible, but it may not shed water as efficiently as directional designs in deep standing water. It is less suited for performance-oriented vehicles where steering feedback is a priority.Pros:- Significantly reduces road noise for a quieter cabin experience
- AquaChannel grooves provide superior wet-weather traction
- Long 65,000-mile tread life warranty for peace of mind
- Built-in tread wear gauge simplifies maintenance checks
Cons:- Softer compound may wear faster under aggressive driving
- Less responsive steering feel compared to sport-touring tires
- Warranty exclusions apply, limiting coverage in some scenarios
Best for: Drivers of mid-size crossovers like the Honda CR-V or Toyota RAV4 who prioritize noise reduction and wet-weather safety.
Not ideal for: Performance enthusiasts who want sharp steering response and maximum grip in dry conditions.
- Size:245/60R18
- Load Index:105
- Tread Life Warranty:65,000 miles
- Construction:Radial
- Season:All-Season
- Max Pressure:51 psi
Our verdict“Choose this if you want a quiet, comfortable ride with reliable wet-weather safety for your daily commuter crossover.”
Goodyear Assurance Finesse All-Season Tire 255/50R20 105T
The Assurance Finesse strikes a balance between cost and capability for larger vehicles. Its wide grooves are effective at clearing slush and water, making it a competent option for mild winter conditions without the price tag of a dedicated winter tire. When compared to the Goodyear Wrangler SR-A, the Finesse offers a more refined highway experience with less road noise, though it lacks the Wrangler’s rugged sidewall protection. The stable shoulder blocks provide predictable handling, which is crucial for heavier SUVs that tend to feel floaty on cheaper tires. However, the symmetrical tread is less aggressive off-road, limiting its appeal for drivers who frequent unpaved paths. It is a sensible upgrade from basic OEM tires.Pros:- Wide grooves effectively evacuate water and slush
- Quiet tread design reduces highway noise significantly
- Stable shoulder blocks improve handling stability for heavy vehicles
- Cost-effective compared to premium touring tires
Cons:- Symmetrical tread lacks off-road capability
- Sidewalls are softer than truck-specific tires
- Tread depth is moderate, limiting long-term snow traction
Best for: Owners of large SUVs who need a reliable, quiet all-season tire for highway driving and light snow.
Not ideal for: Drivers who frequently travel off-road or tow heavy loads, as the sidewalls are not reinforced for rough terrain.
- Size:255/50R20
- Load Index:105
- Tread Depth:10/32 inches
- Construction:4-ply Radial
- Season:All-Season
- Max Pressure:540 kPa
Our verdict“A solid, budget-friendly choice for SUV owners who want better wet traction and quietness than standard OEM tires.”
Goodyear Wrangler SR-A All-Season Radial Tire, P275/60R20 114S
Designed specifically for trucks and SUVs, the Wrangler SR-A offers robust sidewall construction that stands up to curb impacts better than passenger-focused tires like the Assurance ComfortDrive. The zigzag microgrooves are a key differentiator, providing enhanced bite in light snow and ice without the harsh ride of a true winter tire. While the 50,000-mile warranty is shorter than some touring competitors, the trade-off is a tougher, more durable carcass suited for heavier loads. This tire excels in wet-traction compound performance, keeping trucks planted on rainy highways. However, it is not an all-terrain tire; the tread pattern is optimized for road use, so off-road capability is minimal. It is the go-to for drivers who need truck reliability on paved roads.Pros:- Reinforced sidewalls resist punctures and curb damage
- Zigzag microgrooves improve traction in light snow
- Wet-traction compound maintains grip in rain
- Optimized for heavy vehicle load capacities
Cons:- Shorter 50,000-mile warranty compared to touring tires
- Limited off-road performance capabilities
- Sold as a single unit, requiring multiple purchases
Best for: Light truck and SUV drivers who need durable sidewalls and reliable wet-road traction for daily commuting.
Not ideal for: Drivers seeking off-road capability or maximum tread life, as the 50,000-mile warranty is average for this category.
- Size:P275/60R20
- Load Index:114
- Warranty:50,000 miles
- Construction:Radial
- Season:All-Season
- Max Pressure:44 psi
Our verdict“The best pick for truck owners who prioritize sidewall durability and wet-weather safety over off-road prowess.”
Goodyear Wrangler Territory AT All-Season Tire, 275/60R20 115S
The Wrangler Territory AT bridges the gap between highway comfort and off-road aggression. Unlike the Wrangler SR-A, which is strictly for paved roads, the Territory features multi-angle tread sipes and an aggressive wraparound shoulder that provide real grip on dirt and gravel. It is designed to maintain a comfortable ride on pavement, mitigating the harshness typical of all-terrain tires. This makes it ideal for drivers who spend 80% of their time on highways but want the option to take backcountry trails. The trade-off is a shorter tread life compared to highway tires and increased road noise. It is not as rugged as the Wrangler DuraTrac RT, but it is significantly more comfortable for daily driving.Pros:- Aggressive shoulder design provides off-road traction
- Engineered for a smoother ride than typical AT tires
- Multi-angle sipes enhance grip in loose terrain
- High load index supports heavy-duty trucks
Cons:- Higher road noise compared to highway tires
- Shorter tread life due to aggressive compound
- Wheel is not included in the package
Best for: Overland enthusiasts and rural drivers who need a tire that handles both highway miles and occasional off-road trails.
Not ideal for: City drivers who never leave paved roads, as the aggressive tread creates unnecessary noise and wear.
- Size:275/60R20
- Load Index:115
- Tread Depth:11/32 inches
- Construction:4-Ply Radial
- Season:All-Season
- Max Pressure:51 psi
Our verdict“Choose this if you want one tire that can handle your daily commute and weekend camping trips without sacrificing too much comfort.”
Goodyear Assurance Finesse All-Season Tire, P235/60R18 103H
This specific size of the Assurance Finesse focuses on low rolling resistance, making it a smart choice for drivers looking to maximize fuel economy. Compared to the Wrangler Territory AT, the Finesse is significantly lighter and quieter, with a tread pattern optimized for minimal energy loss during rotation. The optimized road contact ensures even wear, which helps maintain efficiency over the tire’s life. It provides adequate traction in wet and light snow, but it is not designed for severe winter conditions or off-road use. The symmetrical tread is simple and cost-effective, but it lacks the advanced hydroplaning resistance of the ComfortDrive. It is the sensible, economical upgrade for standard SUVs.Pros:- Low rolling resistance compound improves fuel efficiency
- Quiet tread design enhances cabin comfort
- Even wear pattern extends tire lifespan
- Cost-effective all-season solution
Cons:- Moderate snow traction compared to dedicated winter tires
- Lower load capacity than truck-specific tires
- Less aggressive wet-weather performance than ComfortDrive
Best for: Fuel-conscious SUV drivers who want a quiet, long-lasting tire for primarily highway and city driving.
Not ideal for: Drivers in regions with heavy snowfall or those who tow heavy loads, as the load capacity and winter traction are moderate.
- Size:P235/60R18
- Load Index:103
- Tread Depth:9/32 inches
- Construction:4-ply Radial
- Season:Year-round
- Weight:28.9 pounds
Our verdict“The best option for budget-minded drivers who want to save on gas without sacrificing basic safety and comfort.”
How We Picked
I evaluated these fifteen Goodyear models based on their specific vehicle applications, treadwear warranties, and sidewall construction quality. The primary filter was intended use: I separated passenger car tires, SUV/Crossover tires, and Light Truck/SUV tires, as mixing these categories leads to unsafe handling or premature wear. I also looked at the temperature and traction grades listed on the sidewalls to gauge real-world wet and hot-road performance, rather than relying solely on marketing terms like “all-season.” Ranking was determined by how well each tire balances its primary strength against its inherent weaknesses. For example, a tire with exceptional off-road capability that produces excessive cabin noise ranks lower for a suburban commuter than a tire with moderate off-road skills and superior quietness. I prioritized models with consistent tread wear patterns and robust load ratings, ensuring that the recommendations reflect long-term value and safety rather than just initial purchase price or brand popularity.
| Goodyear tire | Tread type | Season |
|---|---|---|
| Goodyear Wrangler TrailRunner | Symmetrical | Year-round |
| Goodyear Wrangler Territory HT | — | — |
| Goodyear Assurance All-Season | — | Year-round |
| Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RT | Asymmetrical | — |
| Goodyear Eagle Touring All-Sea | Asymmetrical | — |
| Goodyear Fortera HL All-Season | Non-directional | All-Season |
| Goodyear Eagle Touring All-Sea | Symmetrical | All-Season |
| Goodyear Eagle RS-A2 All-Seaso | Asymmetrical | All-Season |
| Goodyear Eagle LS2 All-Season | Directional | All-Season |
| Goodyear Eagle RS-A P245/50R20 | Asymmetrical | All-Season |
| Goodyear Assurance ComfortDriv | — | All-Season |
| Goodyear Assurance Finesse All | — | All-Season |
| Goodyear Wrangler SR-A All-Sea | — | All-Season |
| Goodyear Wrangler Territory AT | — | All-Season |
| Goodyear Assurance Finesse All | — | Year-round |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Goodyear Tires
Selecting tires is not just about brand loyalty; it is about matching engineering specifications to your vehicle’s weight, speed capabilities, and typical terrain. Misunderstanding these technical details is the most common cause of buyer’s remorse in the tire market.
Understanding Load Index and Speed Ratings
Every tire sidewall displays a load index (a number) and a speed rating (a letter), and ignoring these can compromise safety. The load index indicates the maximum weight each tire can carry when inflated to its maximum pressure. If you drive a heavy SUV like an Explorer or Tahoe, using a tire with a lower load index than recommended by the manufacturer can lead to sidewall failure under stress. Similarly, the speed rating denotes the maximum speed the tire can sustain safely over time. While you may never drive at the rated limit, a lower rating means the tire’s internal structure is not designed to handle the heat generated at higher speeds. Always match or exceed the OEM specifications found in your owner’s manual or on the driver’s side door jamb.
The Tradeoff Between Tread Life and Grip
Tire engineers face a constant conflict: softer rubber compounds provide better grip on wet and dry pavement but wear down quickly. Harder compounds last longer but can feel slippery in rain or snow. Goodyear addresses this through advanced silica tread designs, but the physical tradeoff remains. The Assurance ComfortDrive uses a compound optimized for longevity and comfort, meaning it may not feel as sticky in a hard cornering situation as the Eagle RS-A2. Drivers who prioritize mileage should accept slightly reduced ultimate grip, while performance enthusiasts must accept shorter tread life. There is no tire that maximizes both without significant compromise.
Noise Reduction vs. Off-Road Capability
Aggressive tread patterns necessary for mud and rocks inherently create more noise on paved roads. The Wrangler DuraTrac features large, blocky lugs that bite into loose terrain, but these blocks slap against the pavement, generating a noticeable hum. Conversely, the Assurance All-Season uses a continuous rib design and noise-canceling pitch sequencing to keep the cabin quiet. If you spend 95% of your time on highways, an all-terrain tire will become a source of irritation. Only choose aggressive treads if you regularly encounter unpaved surfaces, as the noise penalty is constant and cannot be fully mitigated by sound deadening.
Seasonal Limitations of “All-Season” Tires
It is a common mistake to assume “all-season” means “all-weather.” In the industry, all-season refers to tires that are legal and safe to use year-round, not tires that excel in extreme conditions. The Goodyear Assurance Finesse will perform adequately in light snow but will harden and lose traction in freezing temperatures compared to a dedicated winter tire. These tires are designed for mild winters and hot summers. If you live in an area with consistent snowfall or sub-freezing mornings, these Goodyear models are a compromise, not a solution. They are best suited for regions with moderate climate variability.
SUV-Specific Construction vs. Passenger Equivalents
Tires labeled for SUVs, such as the Fortera HL and Wrangler Territory, often have stiffer sidewalls and higher load capacities than their passenger car counterparts, even if the size looks similar. This stiffness is required to support the higher center of gravity and heavier curb weight of an SUV. Putting a passenger-rated tire on an SUV can lead to excessive sidewall flex, causing the vehicle to feel floaty and increasing the risk of hydroplaning. When in doubt, look for the “C” (Commercial) or “LT” (Light Truck) designation, or ensure the load index specifically matches your vehicle’s gross weight rating.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I mix Goodyear Assurance and Wrangler tires on the same vehicle?
You should never mix different tire models, especially those from different categories like passenger and light truck, on the same axle or even the same vehicle if it has all-wheel drive. Mixing tires with different tread depths, compounds, or sidewall stiffness causes uneven wear and can damage the drivetrain. For two-wheel-drive vehicles, it is technically possible to run different models on the front and rear, but this is strongly discouraged because it creates unpredictable handling characteristics during braking or cornering. Always install a full set of four identical tires to maintain the vehicle’s designed balance and safety systems.
How does the Goodyear Assurance ComfortDrive compare to the Eagle RS-A2 for daily driving?
The Assurance ComfortDrive is engineered for comfort, featuring a tread pattern designed to minimize road noise and absorb bumps, making it ideal for family sedans and long commutes. The Eagle RS-A2, by contrast, is a high-performance tire with a stiffer internal construction and softer compound for maximum grip and steering response. For daily driving, the ComfortDrive will feel smoother and quieter, while the RS-A2 may feel harsher over cracks and produce more drone. Unless you drive a sports car aggressively, the ComfortDrive offers a more pleasant daily experience, whereas the RS-A2 is reserved for drivers who prioritize cornering limits over ride quality.
Are Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac tires worth the noise penalty for city driving?
For pure city driving, the Wrangler DuraTrac is generally not worth the noise penalty unless you frequently encounter severe weather or rough, unmaintained roads. The aggressive tread blocks create significant road noise on smooth asphalt, which can be distracting in a quiet cabin. Additionally, the softer compound wears faster on city streets due to frequent acceleration and braking. If your driving is primarily paved urban roads, a standard all-season tire like the Wrangler SR-A or Assurance All-Season will provide a quieter, longer-lasting, and more fuel-efficient experience.
What is the difference between the Wrangler SR-A and the Wrangler Territory AT?
The Wrangler SR-A is a highway terrain tire designed for paved roads, focusing on low noise and long tread life. The Wrangler Territory AT is an all-terrain tire with a more aggressive tread pattern, deeper grooves, and reinforced sidewalls to handle gravel, dirt, and light mud. The Territory AT offers better traction in loose conditions but will wear faster and produce more noise on pavement than the SR-A. Choose the SR-A for daily commuting and highway travel, and the Territory AT if you regularly drive off-road or face harsh winter conditions that require more bite.
Do Goodyear tires with higher speed ratings last longer?
No, higher speed ratings typically correlate with softer rubber compounds that provide better grip but wear down faster. A tire with a “V” or “Y” speed rating, like the Eagle Touring or Eagle RS-A2, is designed for performance and heat dissipation, not necessarily longevity. Tires with lower speed ratings, such as “T” or “H,” often use harder compounds that resist wear better and offer longer tread life. If maximizing mileage is your goal, look for tires with lower speed ratings that still meet your vehicle’s minimum requirements, rather than opting for the highest rating available.
Conclusion
To summarize, the Goodyear Assurance ComfortDrive is the best overall choice for most drivers, offering an exceptional balance of quietness, wet traction, and tread life for standard passenger vehicles. For those seeking best value, the Goodyear Assurance All-Season provides reliable performance at a more accessible price point without significant compromises in safety. If you drive a performance sedan or coupe, the Goodyear Eagle RS-A2 is the best premium option, delivering the sharp handling and high-speed stability that standard tires cannot match. For SUV owners needing off-road capability, the Goodyear Wrangler Territory AT is the standout, bridging the gap between highway comfort and trail-ready durability. Finally, for beginners or those with basic commuting needs, the Goodyear Assurance Finesse offers a straightforward, no-nonsense tire that delivers consistent performance with minimal maintenance requirements. Choose based on your primary terrain and comfort priorities, not just the brand name.
